Walking Distance

Our neighbors on Crescent Beach are The Pridwin Beach Hotel and Cottages and Sunset Beach Boutique Hotel. Shelter Island House and Seven B&B are just up the hill. 

A Short Drive Away

Candlelite Inn (Ask for the PMP discount!)
Chequit Inn
Dering Harbor Inn
The Ram's Head Inn

A full list of hotels and B&Bs on Shelter Island is available on the Shelter Island Chamber of Commerce website.

North Fork

Greenporter Hotel (Greenport)

The Hamptons

The Hedges Inn (East Hampton)

For more great Hamptons hotel ideas, visit Travel& Leisure's website